As India gears up for the second Test against England at Edgbaston, the team management finds itself wrestling with what many in cricket circles call a “bad headache”, a set of pressing and complex issues that go far beyond regular team balance or form concerns.
The defeat at Headingley has pushed the think tank to reassess its strategies, especially since the opposition managed a convincing win with a weakened bowling line-up. With England set to return stronger, India faces added pressure to make decisions not just about combinations but also player workload, particularly in light of the long series ahead.
One of the few silver linings from the first Test was the batting performance. India’s top and middle order posted scores above 350 in both the innings, providing some relief in an otherwise disheartening match. That consistency makes changes in the upper order unlikely.
However, there has been some speculation around dropping Sai Sudharsan to move Karun Nair up to No. 3, since Karun Nair appeared uncomfortable at No. 6. While the idea has merit tactically, it could be seen as an unfair demotion for Sudharsan who hasn’t done much wrong.
The more glaring problems lie lower down the order. Shardul Thakur, picked as an all-rounder, failed to deliver with either bat or ball. Skipper Shubman Gill showed little trust in his bowling, choosing instead to overuse his main pacers. Shardul Thakur’s minimal participation in Monday’s net session at Birmingham seems to signal a likely omission. In contrast, Nitish Kumar Reddy has trained extensively and appears set to come in. Nitish Kumar Reddy not only adds more reliability with the bat but can also bowl enough to fill the overs Shardul Thakur would have contributed.
Then there’s the Jasprit Bumrah situation, arguably the trickiest of all. India made it public that Bumrah will only play three of the five Tests in the series, a decision that has drawn criticism and brought intense media scrutiny. Although Bumrah is reportedly fit, as confirmed by Ryan ten Doeschate, the dilemma is whether to risk playing their pace spearhead with the series still open and the team trailing 1-0. The temptation to play him is strong, especially given India’s ongoing struggle to take 20 wickets but preserving him could be wiser long-term.
In Bumrah’s potential absence, the focus shifts to Kuldeep Yadav. Ryan ten Doeschate hinted strongly that India may field two spinners at Edgbaston, with Washington Sundar being mentioned for his batting capabilities. Yet, replacing Bumrah with Sundar could be an overly conservative move, even by coach Gautam Gambhir’s standards who generally prefers deeper batting over pure bowling strength. Kuldeep, on the other hand, offers an attacking option, especially against England’s aggressive Bazball style. He has shown an ability to succeed even when conditions aren’t heavily in his favour and might just be India’s best bet to replicate Bumrah’s wicket-taking impact.
India now faces a defining moment. How they navigate this balance between safety and aggression, not just in terms of team composition but also broader series strategy, may well decide whether they can level the series or continue to fall behind.
