The Indian cricket team is getting ready for the upcoming tour of Australia under the leadership of new captain Shubman Gill but his appointment has also resulted in debates over Rohit Sharma’s place in the Indian squad.
The former cricketer and ex-selector Saba Karim has raised doubts about the logic behind including Rohit Sharma in the squad. He believes that if Rohit is no longer the ODI captain, it suggests the selectors might not see him as part of India’s long-term plans for the 2027 World Cup.
Saba Karim expressed concern about what he sees as a lack of consistency in the selection committee’s planning. Having previously served as both a national selector and BCCI’s General Manager of Cricket Operations, Saba Karim said that such mixed signals could affect team’s direction and clarity.
He argued that if the management has already decided to move on from Rohit Sharma as captain, then they must also be clear about his future role as a player. According to Saba Karim, if the selectors do not envision Rohit playing in the 2027 World Cup, there is little point in keeping him in the team now. He stressed that long-term planning should take precedence over short-term selections, especially with a global tournament only two years away.
The change in the ODI captaincy was announced by the chief selector Ajit Agarkar who said that the decision was made to give Shubman Gill enough time to build his team ahead of the 2027 event in South Africa, Zimbabwe and Namibia. Ajit Agarkar mentioned that balancing three different captains across formats has become challenging and streamlining leadership would help maintain consistency.
Despite the change, Rohit’s contributions to Indian cricket remain immense. He is one of the most successful white-ball captains after MS Dhoni, having led India to three ICC tournament finals, including victories in the T20 World Cup and the Champions Trophy. Even though he fell short in the ODI World Cup final, his leadership and performances have been widely praised.
As the team begins to transition under Shubman Gill, Saba Karim’s comments highlight an ongoing debate in Indian cricket, whether experience should be preserved for stability or phased out in pursuit of a long-term vision.
