When it comes to building a stable financial future, people tend to find a balanced investment approach. Along with investing in high-yielding funds, it is smart to choose some safer options as well. In this regard, Monthly Income Schemes (MIS) and Public Provident Fund (PPF) deserve special mention. These are often favoured by those looking for a predictable cash flow, especially after retirement. However, is seen as a long-term savings instrument that builds wealth slowly but surely.
Here is an analysis of both investment options that can help you choose the one that helps you achieve financial stability by the end of your career.
What are Monthly Income Schemes
MIS are designed to give something back every month. These plans pay out a fixed amount based on the invested capital and applicable interest rates. That’s why they’re often used by people who need a regular income stream, like retirees, parents planning school fees, or even working professionals building a second income line.
There are different types of these schemes. Some are safer, like the Post Office Monthly Income Scheme or senior citizen savings plans. Others come with slightly higher risk and potentially better returns, like mutual fund MIPs, corporate FDs, or annuity plans offered by insurers.
What ties them together is the focus on predictable income. You don’t have to wait till the end of the term to get your money back. You start receiving income within a month of investing, which makes these plans suitable for financial goals that involve ongoing costs.
How is PPF Different from MIS
Public Provident Fund (PPF) works in a different way. Instead of giving you income now, it helps you build a lump sum over time. You contribute a fixed amount every year, and the government pays compound interest on it. After 15 years, you receive the entire amount tax-free. The structure is simple, disciplined, and safe.
But it doesn’t suit everyone. If your primary concern is paying monthly bills, PPF might not be enough on its own. There are no monthly payouts here. You won’t be able to access the funds easily, especially in the first 5-7 years. That makes it better for long-term goals like retirement or your child’s higher education.
Income Needs vs. Savings Horizon: Ask the Right Questions First
Before you pick a plan, start with the basics. Are you saving for a future need or solving for income today? Is this about building wealth or reducing your reliance on a salary?
Let’s say you’re retiring next year. In that case, a mix of guaranteed income options, like a bank fixed deposit with monthly interest or a senior citizen scheme, could help. These options are predictable and carry very low risk. For older adults, that’s often more valuable than high returns.
But if your goal is to build a solid fund over the next 15–20 years, the PPF makes more sense. It’s backed by the government, offers safe returns, and the entire amount at maturity is tax-free. You can also use a PPF account calculator to estimate how much you’ll accumulate based on your yearly contribution.
The difference really comes down to timing. Monthly income schemes start returning value almost immediately. PPF rewards you only at the end, but with interest that compounds quietly and steadily.
How Monthly Income Schemes Stack Up Against PPF
| Product Type | Minimum Investment Period | Returns (p.a.) | Risk Level | Monthly Payouts | Tax Benefits |
| Post Office MIS | 5 years | ~7.4% | Low | Yes | No |
| Senior Citizen Savings Scheme | 5 years (extendable) | ~8.2% | Low | Yes | Section 80C |
| Bank Fixed Deposit (Monthly) | 3 months – 10 years | 4–7% | Low | Yes | Only tax-saver FDs qualify |
| Corporate FD (Monthly) | 1–10 years | 6–9% | Medium | Yes | No |
| Annuity Plans | Varies | 7–10% | Low to Medium | Yes | 80C and 10(10D) benefits |
| Systematic Withdrawal Plans | 6 months+ | Market-linked | Varies by fund | Yes | Only ELSS is tax-advantaged |
| PPF | 15 years | ~7.1% | Very Low | No | Section 80C, Tax-free gains |
The Role of Hybrid Options in Long-Term Planning
For many people, especially working professionals in their 30s and 40s, neither extreme may feel right. You might want some income now, and some savings for later. You may want lower risk, but not at the cost of growth. This is where hybrid options, like insurance-backed income plans, are useful.
Some premium insurance providers, such as Axis Max Life Insurance, now offer annuity-linked products that combine monthly payouts with protection benefits. These are structured in a way that you invest once and then get regular, guaranteed income along with optional life cover.
They also offer flexibility in how long you receive the income, some for 10–20 years, others lifelong. While these don’t have the high growth potential of equity, they do bring clarity and stability, especially in uncertain markets.
Evaluating the Stability Factor: What’s More Reliable in the Long Run?
Let’s come back to the original question: what offers better stability?
PPF scores well on predictability and safety. It’s government-backed, interest is compounded yearly, and your investment is not subject to market forces. If you don’t mind waiting and are focused on long-term goals like a retirement corpus, PPF is hard to beat.
Monthly Income Schemes, on the other hand, give you certainty in the form of scheduled payouts. You know exactly how much you’ll get and when. This is a big plus if your current financial plan includes fixed monthly expenses that need to be covered consistently.
Still, these schemes come in various risk levels. Not all of them guarantee returns. Some, like mutual fund MIPs or SWPs, are market-linked and may not pay the same every month. Others, like corporate FDs, depend on the creditworthiness of the company.
So while the monthly income angle is appealing, it’s not always bulletproof. You need to weigh each product based on your risk appetite, time horizon, and financial goals.
Conclusion
There’s no perfect investment. What you’re really choosing between is stability today versus growth tomorrow. Monthly Income Schemes offer the comfort of regular payouts, but usually with less flexibility and lower post-tax returns. PPF offers long-term growth, tax benefits, and safety, but it asks you to wait.
If you’re trying to strike a balance, it might make sense to split your investment. Lock in a part of your savings in something that pays you every month. Keep the rest growing quietly in your PPF. And if you want to add another layer of protection or predictable income, annuity-linked insurance plans, like those offered by Axis Max Life Insurance, can give you that middle path.
Standard T&C apply
Insurance is the subject matter of solicitation. For more details on benefits, exclusions, limitations, terms and conditions, please read the sales brochure/policy wording carefully before concluding a sale.
Disclaimer: The content on this page is generic and shared only for informational and explanatory purposes. It is based on several secondary sources on the internet and is subject to change. Please consult an expert before making any related decisions.
Tax benefit is subject to change as per the prevailing tax laws.
